Saturday, May 30, 2009

Oh, the Humiliation:Chaos Warriors versus Dark Elves

Battle report below after the fluff. I will separate it with helpful asterisk lines for those of you who wish to skip the fluff.

Among our gaming group there is a general consensus the Chaos Warriors are under costed and over powered. Since I am well aware of their flaws, I am the primary dissenting voice. Of course, since I am also the one who PLAYS Chaos, there is naturally a pro-Chaos bias there. 

Still, though I DO like their stat line, I do NOT think they are under costed. I actually think a couple of their guys are over costed. But that is just me. 

I also think they are saddled with unbelievably worthless units. The Forsaken are worse than the core Chaos Warriors but do cost the same and take up a Special Slot. The Hellcannon works as a Stone Thrower. My history with stuff that can scatter is that it does and very seldom hits what it aims at. Maurauders and Warhounds are "I have nothing else to use the points on so I might as well waste some" units. Chaos Spawns are uncontrollable, hence of quite marginal use.

At the same time they have some fantastic units. Chaos Warriors, if a bit pricey, are still capable of dealing out a lot of damage. Chaos Knights are right there with the Grail Knights for best close combat unit in the game. The Dragon Ogre Shaggoth looks like fun. Their Hero-level characters have stat lines that make them legit threats to other armies' Lord level characters.

Well, with that in mind, I wanted to put a weaker-than-normal army out there and see how it would do. If it won via massacre, I would give serious thought to not playing Chaos. My intention was to lose but keep it a marginal victory. A Draw would be better, a Solid Victory for him acceptable. The only outcomes I did NOT want were being on the wrong end of a massacre or for me to win.

Not that I COULDN'T win...but if I did, it would mean they were right. Chaos is too good. If I can put out an army with intentional gaping flaws and still win...then either my opponent sucks or the army is too good. On the one hand, a Chaos Army will always have a punchers chance...well armored, hits hard, so they can win even if they have a huge points differential, much less simply taking sub-standard units but having equal points. They never should lose the game prior to entering the table, good rolls can overcome that. No doubt the Chaos army IS very solid and capable of winning any game. But there are games they are definite underdogs, and that is what I was shooting for.

See, there is no shooting in the Chaos Army so any shooting army has a distinct advantage. A nimble, maneuvering shooting army such as the Skink Skirmisher army of doom or the Wood Elf army will cause this build fits. Even a Dwarf gun line would have a good chance.

Second, I had nothing to deal with magic. I had the 2 basic Dispel dice and nothing else, so I was very, very susceptible to magic. I carried none myself...no bound spells, no wizards, nothing.

As it turned out, there was a third flaw...but I did not see that one until later.

Well, my plan was changed slightly. I was waiting for Fixed Dice to reply to my e-mail asking him how many points he wanted to play while he was waiting for my reply to his e-mail asking how many points I wanted to play. I never got his e-mail and he never got mine. So last night we talked on the phone and came up with something fun. 

We would each make 6 army lists; 2500, 3000, 3500, 4000, 4500, 5000. We would each roll a d6 so one might end up with 2500 while the other had 5000 or some such wacky combination. 

Then we would roll for scenario, and if one army was significantly larger, would adjust the chart in favor of Ambush or Last Stand type scenarios.

My main problem was I wanted to use as many actual figures without proxying as possible. So I bounced back and forth between putting the finishing touches on another 5 Knights and putting together army lists. 

Did not glue the Knights together, only got 3 lists together. Grabbed the camera, off I went to his place for the game.

We then wimped out on our plan and went with 2500 points. Awesome.

*****************************************************************
The Army List (and the "thoughts" behind it.)
General
I initially went with a Daemon Prince. They can fly, have excellent WS and S, with the Mark of Teentch they have a 4+ Ward Save and they are the only model that can take the 2 best gifts of Chaos. Ironically, I then gave him Word of Agony, a much cheaper but potentially awesome Gift. I then reconsidered; I wanted this army to rely on its troops, so a single model pushing 400 points ran counter to that plan. Also, I wanted to put in another type of unit that he had the perfect base for, so I would use him for that instead. I tossed him out and started over.

I went with a basic Chaos Lord, gave him the Mark of Tzeentch, Talisman of Protection, and Sword of Change. He would have a 2+ save thanks to Chaos Armor and Enchanted Shield (1+ in close combat) and a 5+ Ward Save. The Sword of Change would give him a chance to defeat any opponent; they must make T test and if they fail it, become Chaos Spawn and are removed. That would give me a 17% chance per wound to defeat even a Dragon or some untouchable Lord character. Odds not great but that is what I wanted...a "punchers chance".

Wulfrik the Wanderer
I knew he would field Repeater Bolt Throwers. I suspected as many as 4 but knew there would be some. Wulfrik's ability to enter from any table edge gave me a chance to lessen their impact. At 100 points each, any conversation about units that are too cheap, to me Bolt Throwers are front and center. Hate them. Also, I figured he was my best chance to roll on the Eye of the Gods table.

Army Battle Standard Bearer
I wanted my units to be Stubborn so I gave him the Banner of the Gods which meant he caused Terror and all units within 6" tested as Stubborn. The plan was to put him between the Knights and Warriors up the gut of the field. As a general rule I don't take the Army Standard Bearer as they are relatively fragile and I have not found the banners exceptionally useful.

Exalted Hero
Gave him the Mark of Nurgle to make him harder to hit and gave him the Chaos Runesword which meant he had an awesome WS8, S6 and 5 attacks.

As you can see my heroes could all do serious damage in close combat. They were one of my goals for the game; roll on the Eye of the Gods table.

Core Units
2 identical units of 10 marauders. No upgrades. To keep with my theme of just one proxy, I could only take 10 each as I currently own only 20 Marauder models. When the unit is that small, points on Marks are basically extra free points for the opponent. Lt Armor and Shield is unbelievably worthless; the accursed and woefully under costed Repeater Crossbows of the Dark Elves have a minus 2 to armor save which means anything that wounds a Marauder removes its armor save so why take any upgrades to models that are virtually guaranteed to be casualties? (The irony of that line will be evident in post-battle mop-up)

(24) Chaos Warriors
I took a full command. I had been arguing they were not all that great with a high point cost and low mobility but still hearing they cost too little. So I decided to see if they could win a game. This would be the centerpiece of my army. I gave them the Mark of Khorne to give them Frenzy and the Blasted Standard to give them a 5+ Ward verse shooting. They could take some shooting on their way across the field but still get there with a rank bonus. 

(10) Chaos Warhounds
This is one of those units that I generally would not take. Like the Marauders they are virtually guaranteed to be casualties; low T, no save, low strength. But I planned to use them to go after the bolt throwers and soak up some shooting, plus they fit my idea of using units I typically would not use.

Special Units
I took just one, my beloved Chaos Knights. I have mentioned before this is my favorite unit to use. Knights. However, I decided to go a different route. I took 10 Knights, but instead of 2 5 man units as most people do (and should) take, I went with one 10 man unit. I really have no clue why I did that. I know they are going to take at least one casualty coming across the field which means they get no rank bonus and it means they cannot be in two places at once. Frankly, this was plain and simple a mistake, a brain cramp, a moment of stupidity. I have no explanation for that maneuver. 

Rare Units
I had purchased off E-bay a couple of painted Chaos Spawn. you can take 2 Spawn as a Rare Choice. As a general rule, expensive but fragile troops with a sub-par WS of 3 and no Save are an absolute no-no for me. Add the random nature of their movement and this is the type of unit that is so far from fitting my play-style they might as well be in a different army for as many times as I would play them. 
But they also fit my philosophies for this battle; with 2-7 attacks at S5 (Mark of Khorne) and being unbreakable, they could give me that punchers chance to take out even the toughest opponent.

Last but not least I took the one model I would proxy. This is why I did not use the Prince, so that model could be my Dragon Ogre Shaggoth. Fast, strong, tough, cause terror....they seem like a great model. With 6 wounds, S6, T5 and WS6 he should be able to at least get in a couple of wounds on a Dragon and take out pretty much anything else he came across.

Or not.


So my goals were four-fold:
1) Win a challenge and roll on Eye of the Gods table.
2) Watch the Dragon Ogre Shaggoth demonstrate his awesomeness.
3) See if any of the units like the Warhounds, Chaos Spawn, or Army Battle Standard Bearer would surprise me with their awesomeness
4) Achieve a Draw or lose via Marginal victory.
***************************************
The Setup
Here is where things started to go south. First, I noticed the Prince model was NOT, as I had thought, a Monster-sized base. So instead of the awesome Prince model, I went with an awesome but not as awesome primered Bone Giant model my brother was kind enough to let me borrow. *sigh*

I then noticed that my camera, which I had brought along to document the proceedings, was missing something. Namely, the battery sitting at home on the charger an hour drive each way away.

This, for those paying attention, is the moment I should have packed up and headed home. It was a portent of things to come. 

The field ended up being truly awful. (We roll on the 1995 Battle Book chart to see what is tabled). There were hills in both deployment zones and only deployment zone had a place for me to be out of sight of his Bolt Throwers while still providing me with the ability to move.

Roll to see who chose deployment zone. I rolled a massive 2. Sadly, that would prove to be one of my better rolls of the day. I hoped he would spack out and give me the side he was standing on. I could go to the far edge of the field from his Bolt Throwers and they would have at most one turn to shoot at me. Also, I could use the tower in the middle to protect one flank and the edge of the table to protect the other.

He rolled a 5 and did not, in fact, spack out so I got the bad side of the field.

He put some Repeater Crossbowmen on his left flank behind a fence. Great placement. I knew he would end up putting his Repeater Bolt Throwers on the hill on his right flank, so I put my Warhounds opposite that hill. 

He then put a second unit of the Crossbowmen in front of the hill. At this point I spacked out on my own. I had a hill to the right of my Warhounds, then trees, then space, then trees. For some yet to be explained purpose that made perfect sense when I did it yet for some reason I could not explain by the time it was my turn to place again...I put them in the space. Was I planning to put the Knights behind them and go up the middle of the field? Or the Warriors? Was I...well, i don't know. It was a stupid, stupid placement. They should have gone right behind the Warhounds because with those Repeater Crossbows out there, I would need a second screen.

He then put I think Cold One Knights on his left flank of the crossbows in front of the hill. I put a Chaos Spawn on top of my hill. He dropped a War Hydra on his extreme right, I put the other Chaos Spawn next to the first. His Repeater bolt Throwers went on top of the hill, my Shaggoth went behind the Warhounds. He placed his heroes, I put my Warriors behind the Shaggoth, a some point he put his Corsairs between the Cold Ones and the Crossbows behind the fence, I put the Knights by the hill behind the Warhounds. Wulfrik and a unit of Marauders would hopefully come on soon and hit the Bolt Throwers. I had high, high hopes for Wulfrik. I also named the General on Manticore with Hunter of Men.

We rolled to see who would go first. I rolled a massive 1. Yes, I managed to worsen my roll. On the bright side, it can only go downhill from here.  He rolled a natural 6 but elected to go second. Interesting...I would have thought he would want the extra turn of shooting. Perhaps it was because I was being a jerk and whining about "some day I will get to go first" since in my games I CONSISTENTLY lose the roll to pick table edge and go first. I suspect that is faulty memory...but it FEELS that way. I do feel bad about the whining, it was inexcusable and I hereby apologize for it.

Chaos Turn 1
I rolled a 2 to bring on Wulfrik. No problem, I only had  1 in 3 chance. I bounded the Warhounds forward the full 14", same with the Shaggoth, Knights, and Warriors. The Spawn moved a respectable 5 and 6" each. I cowardly turned my Marauders and moved backwards. No point standing there alone giving his orphan unit of crossbows a target. No shooting, no magic, go.

Dark Elf Turn 1

His dragon flew in from where it had hidden way off on his left flank. Uh-oh...I knew they moved fast, but this could cause problems! His orphan crossbows crossed the fence and started moving towards the battle, which would take place on my left flank.

His magic phase took as long as mine. His shooting, however, was deadly. His crossbows unleashed their hail. 10 crossbowmen killed 6 Warhounds. His bolt throwers did 3 wounds to the Shaggoth. His Dragon-riding dude wounded a Spawn. Ouch. That was a bad phase indeed. On the bright side, I accomplished a rarity...the Warhounds passed their break test. This would not happen again in the entire game.

Chaos Turn 2
I was tired of rolling high, so I rolled  1 to bring on Wulfrik. Then I started the key mistakes. We held quite a round-table debate about this later. It looked to me at the time like his dragon could get to my Knights in his turn which meant he would get the flank charge. I wanted to use the Spawn to protect my flank but did not know how far they would move...one reason I don't like or find useful random units that I don't control. Rules Error. I thought compulsory guys moved AFTER normal ones. And that is how I played it. 

I had to make a choice. I did not think I could get to his units before the dragon got to me. (Later post-game measurements indicate I probably was wrong...he probably would not get to me until the third turn. So I might have had one shot at his Cold One Knights before the dragon was upon me, though he probably would have gotten the charge. With S6 on the charge and my horrific rolling, I still might have gotten at least a few points. His decision to go second looks better and better)

So I moved my Knights and Warriors backwards, planning to use the table edge to protect my flank, my Warriors to protect my rear, and face the dragon charge. This would be a good test for another debate he and I have.

I believe unsupported heroes charging the front of units with advantages like Ranks and Standards can sometimes win but are more likely to lose the combat and flee. He believes heroes in that situation will, if not always, at least usually overcome even -4 or -5 deficits to win the combat. In this one, I would have a starting advantage of 4: +1 for rank, +1 for Standard, +1 for Battle Standard Bearer, and +1 for outnumbering. That would be worth postponing my full blown assault on his lines.

My Warhounds charged his Crossbows and my Shaggoth was out of range so moved towards his Hydra.

His stand and shoot killed the final 4 Warhounds so no close combat.

Dark Elf Turn 2
No charges. Orphan crossbows move closer, Dragon...flies BEHIND the Knights, a brilliant move. War Hydra breath, Repeater Crossbows and Repeater Bolt Throwers put more than the final 4 wounds needed on the Shaggoth. Cross #2 off my list of things to do in this game. 

This was a crushing blow to me. I really, really, really wanted to see him in action. Then again, units I really, really, really want to see in action have a history of disappointing me. Wardancers run off the field to Night Goblin Spearmen, Knights run off the field without taking wounds, Lever 4 Wizard Dragons (Galrauch) do more wounds to themselves than to the enemy...why should a Shaggoth be any different?

His General on Manticore put a second wound on a Spawn.
His Dragon breathed on the Warriors. His dragon has S4 breath to the S3 that my dragons get. Pouty face goes here. A couple of them died.

Chaos Turn 3
The game was essentially over at this point. If he kept flying his dragon around, I had 2 choices; keep maneuvering to avoid giving him the flank or rear charge or just give him the flank or rear charge and try to angle it so he did not pursue into my other unit(s). Either way, it meant I could never get to his peon units that were the ones I wanted to see if my units were truly super superior to. 

Remember the brain cramp where I took one unit of Knights instead of 2? Well, if I could have left one unit for him to charge and positioned it so either he charged that unit or, if my Stubborn unit held even to a flank charge (Battle Standard bearer was USEFUL!) then my Knights might have seen combat. Of course, 5 Knights into 16 bolstered by Malus is one of those things where I believe it is suicide and he believes it is an easy win for me...but I would have done it anyway even if he got the charge. 

On the bright side, Wulfrik did arrive this turn. I brought him on behind the Repeater Bolt Throwers. 
Meanwhile I moved my orphan Marauders into the trees. I would have one table quarter if he forgot about them. Pointless, but at this point I was really grasping at straws...and I had only lost 375 points completely, though a Spawn was close to dying. 

But I could already see he had the maneuver down perfectly. Fly from side to side breathing on me and keeping my Knights and Warriors out of action unless I wanted to give him the flank charge and follow-up into the other unit.

I did get the Spawn into close combat against his Crossbows, who easily passed their Fear test. And I rolled a mighty 5, giving me 6 attacks. Excellent!

Remember I said I seldom take guys with WS3? Well...2 of those mighty 6 attacks hit and, needing 2s to wound, did so. He did not or could not save. I had done 2 casualties! Excellent! He could not wound me back but did pass his break test.

Dark Elf Turn 3
Why charge when you can kill from a distance? He moved his War Hydra back to give him the flank breath, moved his dragon to breath on me, shot a lot, killed 5 Marauders with his Hydra breath and wounded my previously healthy Spawn with his General. On the bright side, his Bolt Thrower whiffed.

And I promptly rolled a 10 for my break test. Epic fail. But wait...Will of Chaos lets me re-roll Panic tests...is this one? Why yes...yes it is. And the re-roll....PASSES. Woo-hoo!

Meanwhile, the Spawn chips away, wounding another Crossbowmen or who outnumber him so the break test is manageable and they make it.

Chaos Turn 4
"Charge!" I actually have several charges. I had unattached my General and Exalted Hero from the Warriors a turn previous trying to position them to charge his dragon (I had also moved the Spawn into the mix. If that Unbreakable model could careen into his dragon, it could buy me some time to do stuff with my units) and the Battle Standard Bearer from the Knights. The Battle Standard and Exalted Hero got the charge on his Black Ark Corsairs. 

I declared a challenge, his Champion accepted. I killed his champ and got something like 2 or 3 overkill. My Exalted Hero had the best roll of the game for me. 5 attacks needing 3s...all 5 hit! Yes! I need just 2s to wound....and managed to roll 3 ones. Whatever. 

Add insult to injury; yes, I won a challenge...but Champions do not allow rolls on the Table.

We miscalculated and thought he had won the combat. I took a test...and failed it. Battle Standard Bearer was part of the combat, re-rolled...and passed. 

Even if we had correctly calculated it (he thought he had a rank bonus of 3 when he only had 2 and I forgot the +1 for Battle Standard...or ANY standard...)he would have been testing on a 9, so it really had no impact on the outcome.

Meanwhile the mighty Wulfrik, facing 2 hapless Repeater Bolt Thrower crewmen used his 4 attacks at WS8 and S5 to do a whopping....1 wound. I then had 5 Marauders attack and do....1 wound. 

Fortunately, he could not wound back. I did 2 wounds and out numbered him...break test at minus 3. I am feeling good. His first roll was for the one within 12" of the General...and that made the difference. He passed. Would have failed on his own. The other guy needed like a 5 and rolled...a 3. They both passed. 

I have to be honest. I thought Wulfrik was borderline broken. I thought he might be under costed at 185 points to have that great stat line and the ability to disrupt enemy war machines. Color me underwhelmed. He cannot even beat worse-than-average line troops when he has all the advantages. 

Dark Elf Turn 4
His general on Manticore charged on Marauder flank while the War Hydra charged the other. His dragon flew around breathing on the Knights while his rider shot the Spawn down. 

Wulfrik and the General entered a challenge. His Hydra killed the other 5 marauders. Wulfrik took no wounds. Awesome, here is where he could redeem himself. This was the challenge I set up with his Hunger of Men ability so I could re-roll to hit and had +2 Strength. I had 4 attacks needing 3s to hit and 2s to wound. 

Color me unimpressed by the zero wounds I did in the one hit (including re-rolls) that I got. 

And yes, I did fail the break test and run 2". And in one of those "rules so stupid they are unbelievable" things, with a Hydra on one side, a Manticore opposite him, a single Bolt Thrower crewmen on the third, do I run to the open spot which would lead them off the table, a happy occurrence for me since both the Manticore and Hydra would have to follow? No, I run "away from the highest unit strength" through the other...which should kill me, not allow me to pass through. That rule was idiotic when I benefited from it against the Brets and is idiotic this time when it...well, didn't really cost me since his Hydra and Manticore were done for this game, but the illogical nature of it annoys me.

Meanwhile his Dragon charged the rear of my two heroes. My Battle Standard bearer entered a challenge with him. Never lived long enough to strike back. My Exalted hero could not even wound his Corsairs. I fled...again, that retarded rule crushed me. Instead of fleeing to the open field to my right or left I fled "away from the highest unit strenght"...his corsairs. 

His Dragon had already moved. My Knights would not get flanked...unless, of course, my fleeing guy ran towards them. He was overrun by both the Corsairs and Dragon with the dragon easily hitting the Knights in the flank...the ONLY way that was going to happen. 

I finally broke his Crossbows with my Spawn and ran into one of his Bolt Throwers while they escaped.

Chaos Turn 5
 Lets see...Knights have been charged in the rear, Warriors are facing away from the Cod Ones who will charge next turn...okay, they reform, General joins them. 

Spawn kills Bolt Thrower, overruns into Crossbowmen, killing them, and ends up 1" from table edge. My first points of the game! Yay!

His Dragon easily dispatches my Knight Champion with lots of overkill, in a shock to nobody I break and flee the table. 

Dark Elf Turn 5
Cold Ones, Manticore, Dragon I think all charged the Warriors. Challenges ahoy. He wins them all, his Knights kill 4 Warriors, his General kills the Champion and in a major upset my General, with 5 attacks with the Sword of Change against his Dragon...does zero wounds. I flee, he pursues, I now have just the Spawn and Marauders on the table. 

Chaos Turn 6
Move the Spawn towards his other Repeater bolt Thrower. Need 6". Roll a 5.

Dark Elf Turn 6
His Hydra breathes on the Spawn or the Bolt thrower shot it or something.  Not much else to do.

End Game
I had 40 points left on the table so he killed 2460. He captured 2 regular standards and the Battle Standard, controlled 2 table quarters, killed my General. Somewhere well over 3000 points.

I controlled a table quarter, wiped out one Repeater Bolt Thrower, and killed 100 points of Crossbows. I got 300 points. 

Pretty clearly, I won this game handily...

Actually, he won because of these things; 
1) I had no way of coping with a flying unit that could get and use a flank charge. His Dragon alone was game-winning. 
2) I had no way of coping with either his Hydra or Manticore
3) He badly outmaneuvered me. His superior army composition combined with excellent tactical movement meant I never had an opportunity. He put his forces in position to be used at best advantage while preventing me from doing the same. 
He out-built my army and out-played me.

True, I suffered from a LOT of hideous rolls...the 3 1s needing 2s was not the only example, nor were things like his hitting 7 of 8 attacks needing 5s. He had some bad rolls as well.

The thing is, even if all those rolls were average for me, I still would have been massacred. His army and use of it were that much better than mine.

One huge mistake MIGHT have moved it to "only" a Sold Victory; had I properly moved my compulsory units first, I would have known how far to move my Knights. He would have had to charge the Unbreakable Spawn. He would have had to completely kill a unit with 3 wounds and T6 in one turn to flank charge my Knights. 

Had the Spawn held for even one turn, I would have at least had a chance to face his Cold Ones. However, if he got the charge it is unlikely I would have even been able to strike back as S6 means he would have killed many of my Knights. But perhaps not. And if I live even a single turn, I could conceivably do enough wounds to cause him some problems. 

Of course, with that said, he also would have had his General on Manticore available to charge so would I have survived that one turn? The Magic 8 ball just laughed.

I am actually happy with this game. It was very valuable from several angles.

1) We did a simulated battle between the General I first took and his Dragon. Had I taken that General, I could probably have staved off his Dragon for a turn or two. At the very least, my own flying super-dude would give me a way to counteract his flying around like that.

2) Yes, we are indeed in Hero-hammer. He who does not come prepared to deal with Monsters will lose every game, probably by massacre. 

3) Chaos is not over-powered in any way, shape or form. Their weaknesses are so huge that they might not be able to beat the Dark Elf army at all, they will struggle with the Wood Elf and Dwarf army, and should do very well against anyone else.

4) Though I know this will be controversial, I will say the most under costed unit in the game is the War Hydra, closely followed by Repeater bolt Throwers, Organ Guns, and Repeater Crossbows. 

5) I should NEVER, EVER, EVER under any circumstance get excited about playing a unit. I waited 15 years to watch the Wardancers suck giant hairy monkey underarm pit sweat,  watched "the best close combat unit in the game" run off the table without doing or taking a single casualty, watched my Power-Magic army get dominated by throw-away, out-level, out-powered wimp wizards, and watched my Shaggoth do nothing but die before getting a chance. That huge target drawback combined with hills always being in my opponents deployment zone means they are just too costly...not to mention the play-test battle we did between my Shaggoth and his Hydra. I outpointed him by over 100 and still lost the battle. Shaggpth; awesome concept, way over priced.Should not have gotten excited about it. I should know better.

But I will try the Shaggoth again. For that matter, I might even try a Chaos Spawn again.
Seeing the power of the flying unit, I think you may see the occasional Disc of Tzeentch in the near future. 

I am happy in that I am getting closer to my stated goal if 50% win rate. I am sorry that a game I wanted to lose caused me to react poorly. He deserved the win due to his build and play and it was extremely childish of me to react the way I did. I do sincerely apologize. I hope my attitude did not diminish your enjoyment of the game because you did a phenomenal job. I hope to see that army again because it should provide a good challenge for anyone and looked like great fun to play. 

Will I use Wulfrik again? Coin flip. Will I use 10 man units of Knights? Probably not. Will I use big Blocks of Chaos Warriors? Maybe in a GIANT game but otherwise probably not. Will I go back to using magic? Unlikely. 


21 comments:

Link said...

Choose the best Modern Side Tables India for your home at theurbandecor.com.They provide a designer furniture to make your dreams become real.

Liam said...

Well that was very interesting. But I do have to bring up the fact that Hero Hammer might be able to be beaten by high combat resolution. Also, if you would have killed the War Hydra's handlers, wouldn't that greatly reduce its effectiveness?

Found some more scenarios in my numerous spare time. (make sure you have some type of .pdf file opener) http://dreadaxe.pagesperso-orange.fr/Warhammer%20Siege%20US.pdf

If that doesn't work, google Warhammer siege pdf, it was the first one at the top.

Liam said...

And I just found The General's Compendium that the previous pdf mentions. If anyone would like to see it I can print a copy and bring it on the next game day.

Darth Weasel said...

We have the General's Compendium, it has some great scenarios for sure.

As for the high combat resolution, that has always been part of my theory. Problem is, the Hydra has such great saves and with its handlers, a total of 13 attacks. Plus you can't attack the handlers per Hydra rules. SO with it attacking 13 times, 7 of them being high strength, good weapon skill attacks, the thing is going to win virtually every combat unless, of course, i do the rolling for it in which case two packs of tube socks that haven't been worn yet could beat it...

Darth Weasel said...

I should add, on the combat resolution, that I mentioned I would have done better with the Goblins...and that is the primary reason.

kennyB said...

Okey dokey, from the other side of the fence (you knew this was coming ^^), and in no certain order:

I will start out by saying I was not offended in any way by anything you said or did. I was disappointed when I perceived that you seemed to give up at setup rather than utilizing your usually impressive generalship to make it an even tougher fight. I was glad we stuck around for the round table afterwards to talk about tactics among other things. And the reason I let you have the first turn was because my Repeater Crossbows have a range of 24", so they are useless until somebody moves, preferably not them. I don't believe that since we started playing Warhammer again I've ever taken the first turn when given the option.

Costing in general is hard to get right. It is also always easier to see how much an opponents troops should cost more over your own. Every once in awhile, we are in agreement that some cost or another is correct, but that would probably be an exception, not a rule. Some are easier to say than others, like when they have a specific role. However, if played outside of that role, they become seemingly much more overcosted. Like if I never fired a shot with a unit of Repeater Crossbowmen, and they got stuck in hand to hand, they would be overcosted in that situation as a 80 pt unit of 20 Marauders would easily pick them apart. However, if instead my 10 man 100 point unit kills 7 Marauders as they charge across the field, and then my unit dies or runs from the Marauders, or even has a fairly even close combat with them, it seems closer to correct. The same would be true in the opposite, if that same 80 pt group of 20 Marauders marched 1 turn instead of 2, and just stood there and got shot down, they would seem overcosted even at 80 pts for 20. With that said:

Hydra's do seem to be overcosted. I have only had one in one battle, but he did kill 6 Marauders. o.O
But after the game we did a 1-vs-1 Dragon Ogre Shaggoth vs War Hydra, and the Hydra killed the Shaggoth with 1 wound remaining. That does seem a little out of whack, with the Hydra costing only 64% of what the Shaggoth does.
As to the costing of the Reaper Bolt Throwers, for 100 pts you get a War Machine that has a 66% chance, at best, to hit each turn. Usually fires 2-4 times per game, and is fodder other than that. Rarely do they do 100 pts of damage each, but they are terrifying to see. With a hill in the deployment zone guarded by a unit to intercept the first incoming unit, it becomes 3-5 turns they can fire, but still is iffy as to whether they can do their points value in damage before being overrun or reduced to just sitting there while close combat ensues around them.

kennyB said...

cont. from last post:

Repeater Crossbows are Strength 3, and have Armour Piercing, a grand total of -1 to Armour Save. You must be mixing them up with the dwarf guns, that get Strength 4, Armour Piercing, and +1 to hit. Nasty little buggers they are. The multi shot option Dark Elves have I obviously love as even if it takes me to needing greater than a 6 to hit, I will use it every time. The odds of killing any decent troop with a shot that is Strength 3, -1 Armour Save is so bad, you need the added quantity to have a chance.

I agree with your assessment of your Warriors(beginning of your post). However, they never moved from their initial location during the entire game, severely limiting their potential as close combat monsters.

I agree with your assessment of your Warhounds, and will re-iterate (since you already iterated in your post) that they soaked up two turns of shooting from 50% of my Repeater Crossbow units, giving more time for your hand to hand troops to cross the field without taking as many casualties from shooting.

The Shaggoth was a blow away surprise. I hit it with both Bolt Throwers on single shot and averaged (I think) 1 wound each per turn with them. The highest % they have done in any game to date. Then my Repeater Crossbows hit a below average %, and then wounded the Shaggoth and Spawns, which in my opinion is the more important and difficult of the two things to accomplish (wounding). I was surprised when (I think twice!) I hit 4 of 20 shots needing 4's, and wounded 1 of 4 each time needing 6's. Uncanny!

As to my Dragon Breath being Strength 4, so is yours. Well, one of the 2 attacks each turn you get with your Dragon Breath is, and it's Flaming! The other is your Strength 2 with a -3 to Armour Save Breath Attack. 2 Breath Attacks. Plus, you have 6 attacks on your profile to my 5. All for 40 points (320+12.5%=360...12.5%!!) more than my dragon costs. I would pay that! An extra Breath Attack and an extra physical attack at WS:6 and S:6 for 40 pts? You bet your buns!

I think 5 Chaos Knights against 16 Cold One Knights is a win for the charger, because if I charge I should hit somewhere around 75% (50% and then 50% again of the misses) and wound 84% (2+), with you saving on a 4+ (50%). It's -4 to save because I almost always take the Banner of Murder with my Cold One Knights, which gives them Armour Piercing just to deal with other Knights. So in a 5 man to 5 man front rank I should do 3 wounds assuming I have both a Dreadknight (champion) and Malus in the group. If you get the charge, you hit 50%, wound 84%, and I save 50%, so you would do 2-3 wounds, reducing my chance of wounding back to 0-1. Of course, with Malus and my Dreadknight locked into challenges, I'll actually theoretically kill less of your frontline on my charge, and you will do more return wounds because of it. Yech!

I had my general within 12" of most of my units that had to take Break tests throughout the whole game- which is the only thing that saved me time and time again. Lucky for my because normally I send my general straight into the fray. But no fray got close enough.

The Wulfrik combat was pure bad luck on his part. Not only could he not wound crewman (fodder), I rolled a 7 needing a 7 (4+3) and a 4 needing a 5 (3+1) for the resultant break tests. If Wulfriks rolls hadn't been so bad, or mine not so good, the potential was there for a major swing in the battle with me being pincered and all my ranged troops being smashed. But Wulfrik got to pondering about Ogre Women or something, and fell asleep when he had the chance to shine. R.I.P. Wulfrik. May you dream about bearded women forever.

@Liam
You can't attack the Hydra's handlers if you have the opportunity to attack the Hydra. And if you kill them, I just roll on the Monster Reaction Table.

kennyB said...

The Hydra 7 WS 4 attacks, Scaly Skin of 4+ (so usually 6+ or nothing) and Regen (4+). The handlers have 3 attacks each at WS 4, S 3, and have no armour but can't be attacked unless you have probably a 5 or 6 man (or wider) front rank as if you have the option to attack the Hydra, you must. So the combination is pretty fierce. And any shooting that is randomized hitting automatically gets distributed 100% on the Hydra, the odds are low to kill it at range without artillery or dwarven guns.

Liam said...

I guess to some degree this basically boils down to luck. Luck of the roll and luck of the... well, roll. Even if you had an flawless army list and a flawless setup with a board side that favors your army, rolling ones the entire game will ruin you in thye fighting stages.

While Ken did seem to get great rolls most of the game and Drew had dice rolls on the slightly bad side, I can't help but wonder what would have happened if your guys' rolls had switched around in every dice situation.

Darth Weasel said...

As for the Repeater crossbows, good call, and also evidence that my Knights are wildly over costed. Because of your crossbows, I can never get the charge on your Cold ones. We both have 14" charge range I believe. Between your crossbows and Bolt Throwers, if I do not move forward, you win the game by shooting. If I do move forward, unless you make a bigger mistake than I have seen you make since we started playing again, I can never get the charge and I cannot win a combat with your Cold Ones if they get your charge.
Example; in your 16 Cold ones verse 5 Knights with ME getting the charge, you say I do 2-3 wounds and you do 0-1. Lets say I do 3 and you do 0, the best case "standard" outcome. The combat is a draw.

You have a rank bonus of 2 and outnumber me, thus tying the combat. Assuming we both have a standard and musician, the combat is a draw meaning the next turn I have but 4 Knights and your rank bonus is not just one.

I suspect you agree with me that the Hydra is way UNDER costed, not over costed. No way is it too cheap :-)

I would argue the Repeater Bolt Throwers, just like the dragons, do not have to actually do as much as they cost to be worth what they cost. For example, even if they never do a single casualty, the THREAT of being shot either forces me to alter my preferred approach or tactics or else I lose. Because they are so powerful, they control portions of the battlefield and allow you to use other units to their fullest advantage. Combined arms tactics beat one-trick wonders which is one reason I believed before the lack of shooting in the Chaos army seriously limited its deadliness.

As for Liam, actually...the dice rolls did not matter a bit. This game was completely decided by army composition and maneuver.

I will finish this in a follow up

Darth Weasel said...

Liam, regarding dice rolls: let's see what would happen if nearly every dice roll went my way.

When Wulfrik comes onto the field, he charges into both Repeater Bolt Throwers on turn 2. He kills 2 guys as expected, the Marauders kill the other 2. I overrun into the Repeater Crossbowmen who then die quicker.

Instead of the 200 points I scored, I now have 300. He then flank charges me with his General on Manticore and War Hydra. Wulfrik and his unit are going to lose that battle and flee so the net result of better rolls there are 100 points scored for me with the same losses.

When my 2 heroes charge in, if they do a reasonable number of casualties, and I do not think 5 -6 is too few to expect, the Black Ark Corsairs are going to be testing on about a -3 (he had a couple of ranks and a Standard and outnumbered me) or -2. Lets say the best case scenario for me happens and they break. I now have 500 points and he does not get his dragon into me.

He will still get the charge on my Warriors in turn 5, the outcome is unlikely to be any different. My Knights now will get flank and/or rear charged by at least two of the following; General on Manticore, 16 Cold One Knights, Dreadlord on Dragon. They die anyway.

Depending on what I did with my Heroes, I may save 500 points of them. I have now scored 500 points, lost 2000 points plus 2 standards and my General. He controls 2 table quarters to my one.

He still wins a crushing victory of something like 2300 to 600.

And that is with every die roll going my way.

Well, except Wulfrik coming on in turn one which is a low-percentage play as 67% of the time he will not and even if he does, Ken can use his War Hydra and Manticore to protect his Bolt Throwers by charging the moment I come on the field. So in a sense, Wulfrik not coming on earlier may have saved him as the General probably would have charged him on turn one whereas by turn 3 he was distracted...

So while I would like to say the dice played a roll, the cold hard truth is they meant absolutely nothing. No, Ken crushed me with army composition and tactics.

If he uses his dragon poorly, I can potentially overcome the composition thing to achieve a draw. But so long as he does not advance other troops and uses his dragon to neutralize my Knights and Warriors, the dice are not going to matter in that game one whit.

John said...

Nice detailed write up Darth.

kennyB said...

We come back around to hypotheticals a lot around here. lol
IF the dice rolls were different, and IF you used a more aggressive tactic to cross the field so your 40 points of Marauders occupied my flanking 100 point unit of crossbowmen for a couple turns (or even suckered my Dragon for a turn or 2), AND your 500 points of Knights AND your 1k block of Warriors and Hero's approached my troops behind your Shaggoth and Warhounds who took all the shooting I had for 3 turns, AND Wulfrik came in from the rear between turns 2-3, AND your Spawn were occupying some of my forces (you mentioned aiming them to occupy my Dragon Hero), perhaps we would be reading a much different report.
Because that was what I expected.

I figured you would go for the Bolt Throwers and middle troops with your mid or throw-away units, requiring me to flank from either or both sides to save them, then you could hit my flank with your Spawns and your Knights and probably your Shaggoth, leaving my Dragon or Hydra to join in a flank or a rear (which doesn't do as much since you would've been stubborn), and your reserve unit whatever it may be, would come in to his rear or flank. AND in fact, Wulfrik could have been brilliant in that instance, working as assassin and Rear Intruder. Instead, Chaos fell victim to Fear of the Dark Elves, and let that dictate their entire strategy! Mwah hah ha! YOU WILL ALL FEAR THE ARMY OF KENDOPOLIS, KENITHIA, GREATEST OF ALL DARK ELF CITY'S!

kennyB said...

I hate the character # limit...Drew, you know what I'm talking about! The least it could do is track how many characters I've used onscreen so I know when to stop blabbing and start my next post! It took me so many tries to get it broken up acceptably yesterday, you posted while I was trying to! Anywhoooo.....

I believe that something with the likelihood of doing something incredible should raise cost more than something with just the potential to do something incredible. My elite troops consistently perform very well, and so they may be undercosted. My Bolt Throwers consistently perform underwhelmingly, rarely stepping out from the shadows to do something really impressive. I do not think the Bolt Throwers are undercosted JUST because they have the POTENTIAL (I really just want to put words in italics, but am not good with html) to do great things, as the likelihood points to that not being the case. If 2 of them had a high (75%+) chance of killing 300 points in enemy troops every game, I would say undercosted. But with them having much less than that, I don't think they are. They are brittle, finicky things that are less powerful and less likely to blow up than artillery, but also a fair bit less likely to careen through my enemy demolishing them with Strength 10 "no roll to hit" hits. You add killing blow to my Bolt Throwers, or even Poison, and I'll say they are ridiculous. But as they are, usually hitting 1-3 times per game and wounding 5 out of 6 times, I think they are about right. Except against the Ogres as last time, I rolled a 1 or 2 needing a 2 or 3 to hit or wound several times. Of course, I AM the one USING them. Perhaps when it is my Tomb Kings versus Rick's High Elf Bolt Throwers I will change my mind. rofl. NOT MY SKELE'S!

As far as the Hydra, with a move of 6 (handlers too), I believe he is likely to do more than 175 points in every game he can reach the enemy (so not against the dwarves or possibly the wood elves). That makes him undercosted. Not because he COULD 1 in 6 games do more damage than his points value indicates, but because 5 out of 6 games he WILL (hypothetical again) do more than his points value indicates. But hey, it's easy sitting in the almost undefeated chair here, defending my troops. This is my first time on this side of the fence, and I LIKE IT! I have decided to do my next battle (non-campaign only) without my Dragon, so whoever faces me take that into tactical consideration.
*under breath* you will face my dreadlord on manticore and my hydra though, but still no magic most likely... *mumble mumble*

Liam said...

My my my my my. These are some mighty lenghty replies. I feel I should just type random things to keep up with you guys. Or maybe I will start randomly advertising furniture on blogs unrelated to furniture. But yes I guess I overestimated luck and the dice.

And in a segway, what point value of an army list should have ready for the campaign kick off day?

Darth Weasel said...

IF the dice rolls were different, and IF you used a more aggressive tactic to cross the field so your 40 points of Marauders occupied my flanking 100 point unit of crossbowmen for a couple turns (or even suckered my Dragon for a turn or 2), AND your 500 points of Knights AND your 1k block of Warriors and Hero's approached my troops behind your Shaggoth and Warhounds who took all the shooting I had for 3 turns, AND Wulfrik came in from the rear between turns 2-3, AND your Spawn were occupying some of my forces (you mentioned aiming them to occupy my Dragon Hero), perhaps we would be reading a much different report.
Because that was what I expected.
Your flanking unit of crossbowmen, to the best of my knowledge, never did a thing in the game and my Marauders could not either.

And the more I think about it, the less convinced I am that the game would not have been shorter with actually an even worse outcome for me had I used the Spawn to charge-block your dragon and continue advancing. Had I done so, 2 things would have happened.

1) Your dragon most likely would have 1-turn killed the Spawn and flank charged them in the second turn since the Spawn were about 5" closer to your dragon. Spawn have WS3 and T5 which means you hit and wound on 3+, with you re-rolling thanks to Eternal Hatred with 6 attacks. You were consistently getting 5 hits in that case which means doing 3 wounds was not exactly a long shot, so that strategy would have been disastrous for me.

2) As discussed previously, your Cold Ones and General/Manticore would have gotten the charge (and possibly even your Manticore!) which means my Knights would once more have been shredded.

No, lets call this what it was. You built a better army that if we played 100 times, I would be fortunate to salvage a win out of that scenario.

Regardless of what I did, I had nothing to block you from flank-charging my Knights which left me nothing to deal with either the manticore or Hydra, much less both of them.
The more I think on the game, the more I think I actually played it correctly which is very, very discouraging. The only thing I could have done different was set up on the far side of the field which means I would not have been able to maneuver at all so your Dragon and Manticore would have, what is the phrase...pwned me big-time.

That is a game I never had a chance in and it had nothing to do with luck.

Darth Weasel said...

* I meant possibly even your Hydra, not the Manticore which I already accounted for

kennyB said...

I think my flanking crossbowmen wheeled and shot one of your Spawns, but maybe they shot AT it more than shot it.

Buy furniture now at the Kenopolis Emporium of Furniture and Torture Devices. Buy a mattress, get a stretch-device (rack) free! Closed Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday through Saturday.

Fullur said...

The problem with saying "if this die roll went this way" is that it assumes had the result of a die roll changed the following decisions would not. For instance, if Wulfrik had shattered the Bolt Throwers as expected perhaps the Manticore would have been forced to deal with him. Perhaps not, but that is the kind of difference that can be made by the change of a die roll.

kennyB said...

It's hard to believe that the best course of action is ever to split up an army, and do nothing with the majority of it. To not even set any kind of trap, to just leave the troops to their fate, is not a sound battle tactic. Instead of lining up one group to lure the enemy off of a table edge, so that you can get a charge when your enemy returns from off field, or instead of running headlong across the battlefield to inflict as much damage as you can before you die....to just sit and spin until you die knowing that utter defeat is the inevitable outcome of your chosen maneuver is not a sound tactic. In a battle where you have no ranged tactic, you must not stay at range. It is a guaranteed defeat. To say that doing nothing is the best you can accomplish is a defeatist attitude. If you don't try, you can't succeed. All of you reading take heed:
Do not ever look at a battle and decide it is unwinnable. For that is the only way it will ever be unwinnable. If you decide you can't win, and so you don't really try, you can't win. If you decide you can win, and give it your best, you can win, and indeed do win, even if the battle is lost. At least for the first ten or fifteen losses, after that it may really be factually unwinnable.....just ask me or Fullur.....

Darth Weasel said...

Fullur, in this case the Manticore actually did very little damage...the most damage from that particular general was via Repeater Crossbow. He had little impact on the battle.

You are completely correct, though, one outcome USUALLY changes the future.

As for the battle, I have thought about it repetedly and once I set my units the way I did and made the move I did on the first turn, the more I think about it the more I know I actually moved everything almost correctly from that point on. Had I released my Heroes earlier, they possibly could have held off the dragon for a moment, but as we now know, it simply would have meant the destruction of the Knights to the Cold Ones instead who would have gotten the charge and the Knights would have been out of range of the BSB since he would be back trying to deal with the dragon. So I still would have suffered a masacre.

Instead, I should have set up in the crowded far corner of the board which, incidentally, kills what is usually my biggest advantage with Chaos, maneuverability, and sit there making you come to me.

But that is A) boring and B) the best outcome I can hope for there is a draw anyway.

That was a battle where the respective armies we took, if we were to play that game 100 times, you win 99 or more of them.

I stand by the maneuvers I did after the first turn. If I somehow induce you to flank charge my Knights and get you to pursue off the table, that leaves only the block of Warriors to take out your army. They are too slow and too weak as we saw when your Cold One Knights obliterated them in one turn...and that was without using your War Hydra and with your Manticore/Dreadlord doing zero wounds.

That field with those armies could have no other outcome.